best defender in the prem?

[Esox Lucius]

john terry for me, skillfull mother****er.

[Maxima]

Yeah terry for sure hes the daddy and id probaly have to say Gary nevile though I absolutly hate united he still has to be the most consistant and id feel safe playing along side him!!

[Col]

lucas radeba is the man. a true professional, brave, comitted, exellent in the air (wins everything), strong, and some of the tackles & blocks this guy makes are out of this world.

and he does all of the above continuosly playing through pain, and has done for some time. and hes 35 yrs old.

well thats my biased decision. well he used to be the best, and i think hes still up there with the best of em.

best in the prem? john terrys good, not the best. and gary neville? please. :lol: i admit that hes pretty steady and full of experience, but on the occasion his postional sense of play is crap.

im going to go with ferdinand, although i dont think hes been at his best since moving to the scum.

[Esox Lucius]

ferdinand is shit.

[Hakka.]

John Terry is very very good. Admire him a lot.

John Woodgate is very good too and has a lot of potential still and even when he's fresh back from injury he looks so comfortable in defence.

[Esox Lucius]

yeah I agree woodgate is a good player.

[Col]

yeah I agree woodgate is a good player.

at least we agree on something. give woody a good run of games and we'll see the class come out. hes been on the sidelines too long with injurys & the infamous GBH case. woodgates one of the few players that have left our club and still recieve respect from our fans.

[Hakka.]

yeah he does get injured too easy, but he is bloody class. I was so pleased when he sigend for the toon... they just need to get another defender like him! if we can for another £9million then fair play.

[Spooney]

Gary Neville is feckin shite! Extremely overated player how does he get in the England team :nono:

[Esox Lucius]

southgate anyone? opinions?

[Col]

southgate isnt bad, a good defender actually, i wouldnt have him in the england team mind.

[subsonic]

tony hibbert one for englands future but right now sol campball or john terry

[Hakka.]

southgate anyone? opinions?

Used to love him... think he's getting on now. In his day he was very good defender. Doesn't get as much credit as he deserves.

Probs be remembered for the penalty miss more than anything.

[subsonic]

southgate anyone? opinions?

Used to love him... think he's getting on now. In his day he was very good defender. Doesn't get as much credit as he deserves.

Probs be remembered for the penalty miss more than anything.

that is true he was is a class act but he will be rememberd for that pen